A critique from an Indigenous Lens (Hailey Hill)

    The way Indigenous people are portrayed in mainstream media is honestly a frustrating paradox of "too much" and "not enough" at the same time. On one hand, you have the classic "Dances with Wolves" or Avatar trope—the hyper-spiritual, eco-warrior archetype who exists mainly as a backdrop for a white protagonist’s character development. It’s what critics call the "Mystical Native" or "Noble Savage" trope, and it’s exhausting because it traps actual living, breathing cultures in a static, pre-colonial museum exhibit. When a movie like Avatar uses Indigenous struggles as a aesthetic for a sci-fi rant without actually involving Native voices in the creative driver's seat, it feels less like solidarity and more like a high-budget costume party.

    Realistically, the "powers-that-be" in Hollywood and news media have spent decades flattening diverse tribal nations into a single, tragic monolith. We see plenty of stories about trauma or historical victimization, but where are the stories of Indigenous joy, modern-day success, or indigenous-led futurism? There is a massive shift happening right now with shows like Reservation Dogs or Prey, where Native creators are finally getting to tell their own stories with humor and nuance. But until the industry stops looking at Indigenous people as "problems to be solved" or "relics of the past" and starts seeing them as contemporary leaders, the media's lens will remain fundamentally broken.

    If you want a very good perspective: Native Media Theory on YouTube is a wonderful creator that talks about Indigenous issues in media and in general.

https://www.youtube.com/@nativemediatheory
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lMwKQmrNsKg

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Sarah Chapman- Homelessness Countering the Destruction of Home by Kip Redick

Reading Homelessness Countering the Destruction of Home by Kip Redick challenged the way I think about both ecology and spirituality. What struck me most is the idea that “home” is not just a physical structure but an event, a lived relationship. Drawing from Martin Heidegger, Redick describes dwelling as a kind of embodied participation in a community that includes not only humans, but also earth, sky, plants, animals, and even tools. I found myself reflecting on how rarely I actually experience that kind of dwelling. So often, I move through spaces quickly, distracted, or focused on productivity rather than presence. However, as I have continued to take classes with Dr. Redick, I try to be more intentional and aware of nature. The essay made me more aware of how deeply modern technology shapes the way I relate to the world. Through thinkers like Jacques Ellul and Emmanuel Levinas, Redick argues that we have turned the world into “standing reserve”, something to be used efficiently ra...
Read more

Iroquois Creation Story Paper Presentation (Amanda Capper)

 During today's class, one of our classmates shared her essay on the Iroquois creation story. I thought this was actually really interesting, because I had never heard of it before. One thing that struck me as particularly interesting was the main theme of reciprocity and balance. For example, the earth (Gaia) as an independent resource was interesting to me. Through Gaia, other environmental constituents also spring up, such as trees, grasses, dirt, the ocean, the rivers, etc. These features give humanity sustenance, breadth, and life. This is where the reciprocal practices come from. Using these materials and the natural world for our benefit, yes, but there's more to life than just this.  I've always thought that the Native worldview is so much better than our own worldview. I think when we get so involved in ourselves, materialistic and capitalistic culture, we lose sight of what really matters - community and the ecosystem we live in. Its not just about the things we h...
Read more

Kip Redick Introduction

Welcome to the Religion and Ecology blog for 2026. Make sure to start the blog with your name and the subject of the entry (Just as I have done with this post). Blog entries will be considered informal writing assignments and as such will be graded more in relation to content than style. Blog entries will contain questions and answers to questions, as well as reflections which relate to daily classroom discussions, completion of exercises, and reading assignments. Any questions the student has when reading or completing assignments should be written in their blog. Reflections may relate to connections the student makes between discussions in this class and those in other classes, between arguments raised in the readings in this class and those raised in other classes or in informal conversations. Students are encouraged to apply the ideas learned in this class to activities that take place outside of the class. These applications make great reflections. The student s...
Read more